The Relationship of Democratic Implementation to Job Satisfaction of Civil Servants in Binh Duong Province – Vietnam

Nguyen Thi Kieu Diem

Master’s student – Vietnam National Academy of Public Administration

ABSTRACT: This research investigates the impact of democratic principles on job satisfaction among civil servants in Binh Duong Province. The study uses qualitative methods such as interviews and surveys to identify a positive correlation between participatory decision-making, transparent communication, and heightened job satisfaction. Conversely, bureaucratic complexities, power imbalances, and limited civic engagement opportunities pose potential challenges. The findings contribute to understanding democracy’s role in public administration, offering practical insights for policymakers aiming to improve the working environment for civil servants. This qualitative approach provides a nuanced perspective on the subjective experiences of civil servants, emphasizing the importance of democratic principles in shaping their professional fulfillment and overall job satisfaction.

KEYWORDS: Democratic implementation; Job satisfaction; Civil servants; Binh Duong Province; Vietnam; Public administration; Governance practices

INTRODUCTION

In the global landscape, democratic governance fosters transparency, citizen participation, and institutional accountability (Fung & Wright, 2001). Implementing democratic principles not only shapes the political landscape but also significantly influences the functioning of public institutions, including civil servants’ job satisfaction (Fox & Stoett, 2016). This article delves into the intricate relationship between democratic implementation and civil servants’ job satisfaction in the dynamic context of Binh Duong province, Vietnam.

Vietnam, a nation with a rich history and a unique political landscape, has gradually evolved its approach to democratic governance (London, 2013). Against this backdrop, Binh Duong province emerges as a distinctive setting for our study. Located in southern Vietnam, Binh Duong is renowned for its rapid industrialization and economic growth, making it a microcosm of the nation’s development. As the province transforms governance structures, understanding the impact of democratic principles on civil servants’ job satisfaction becomes pivotal (Kettl, 2015).

The relevance of this study lies in the intersection of two crucial elements: the ongoing democratic reforms within the Vietnamese political system and the professional landscape of civil servants in Binh Duong. Exploring how the democratic framework aligns with the experiences and contentment of civil servants provides insights into the functioning of public administration and contributes to the broader discourse on governance in rapidly evolving societies.

As we embark on this exploration, the intricate dynamics between democratic ideals and the job satisfaction of civil servants in Binh Duong will be unraveled, shedding light on the nuanced interplay between political structures and the daily professional lives of those instrumental in implementing public policies.

LITERATURE REVIEW

Relationship between Democratic Practices and Job Satisfaction

The concept of democracy, with its roots deeply embedded in ancient philosophies and modern political thought, has undergone a nuanced evolution in Vietnam. Historically, Vietnam has experienced various forms of governance, from feudal systems to colonial rule. The introduction of socialist principles following the reunification of North and South Vietnam in 1976 marked a significant juncture in the nation’s political trajectory (Lee et al., 2011).

Over the years, Vietnam has undertaken deliberate steps towards political reforms, adopting a socialist-oriented market economy and gradually incorporating elements of a multi-party system. The political landscape has witnessed a shift towards increased transparency and citizen participation. Notably, the 2013 Constitution of the Socialist Republic of Vietnam reinforced the commitment to democratic principles, reflecting the evolving aspirations of the Vietnamese people.

Research examining the relationship between democratic practices and job satisfaction among civil servants is a burgeoning field that draws upon organizational behavior, political science, and public administration literature (Ritz et al., 2017). Several studies have explored the impact of democratic governance on the job satisfaction of public employees, shedding light on the intricate dynamics at play (Meijer, 2013).

Public Administration and Democratic Governance

Scholars have extensively deliberated upon the nexus between democratic practices within public administration and the consequential impact on civil servants’ job satisfaction. Frederickson and Ghere (2005) assert that democratic principles are pivotal in enhancing job satisfaction, primarily by fostering a heightened sense of involvement and empowerment among civil servants. The essence of democratic governance lies in promoting inclusivity and participation, allowing civil servants to feel more engaged in decision-making processes (Cornforth,2 004). By facilitating participatory decision-making mechanisms, democratic practices enable civil servants to contribute actively to policy formulation, thus imbuing their professional roles with purpose and influence (Fischer, 2009).

Moreover, the emphasis on open communication channels is underscored as a fundamental tenet of democratic governance in public administration (Kettl, 2015). Civil servants derive enhanced job satisfaction when afforded transparent and accessible communication avenues. This openness ensures that relevant information is disseminated efficiently and engenders a culture of trust and collaboration within the organizational framework (Welch et al., 2005). The scholarly discourse posits that these democratic attributes create a conducive environment wherein civil servants feel acknowledged, valued, and integral to the overarching goals of public administration (Men et al., 2014). Consequently, the empowerment and involvement facilitated by democratic practices emerge as foundational elements contributing substantively to civil servants’ job satisfaction.

Social Exchange Theory

As expounded by Blau in 1964, Social Exchange Theory serves as a comprehensive theoretical framework that elucidates the intricate dynamics underlying the relationship between democratic practices and the consequential levels of job satisfaction among individuals within public administration. This theoretical perspective posits that the perception of the value and reciprocation of one’s contributions within an organizational setting significantly influences the subjective experience of job satisfaction. According to Social Exchange Theory, the nature of exchanges within a social context forms the basis for individuals’ assessment of their workplace satisfaction (Cameron & Webster, 2011).

In the specific context of democratic practices, the theory contends that when civil servants perceive their inputs and efforts as recognized and reciprocated within the democratic decision-making processes, a positive correlation with elevated job satisfaction ensues (Bettencourt et al., 1997). This reciprocity reflects the essence of democratic governance, where individuals’ voices and contributions are acknowledged and actively integrated into the decision-making mechanisms (Van Knippenberg & Sleebos, 2006). Consequently, the participatory nature of democratic practices, where civil servants’ viewpoints are considered and valued, aligns with the tenets of Social Exchange Theory.

Within this theoretical framework, the democratic milieu becomes a platform for a social exchange wherein civil servants invest their intellectual and professional capital, expecting a return in the form of acknowledgment, influence, and a sense of fulfillment (Neff, 2008). In turn, the organizational climate cultivated by democratic practices becomes conducive to reciprocation, thereby fostering a positive exchange dynamic and contributing to elevated levels of job satisfaction among civil servants. This symbiotic relationship between democratic practices and Social Exchange Theory provides a nuanced lens through which to comprehend the intricate interplay of social dynamics within public administration and the consequent impact on the job satisfaction of civil servants.

Institutional Theory

Institutional theory, as expounded in the seminal work of Meyer and Rowan (1977), presents a theoretical framework that posits the profound impact of the institutional environment on shaping organizational practices (Li et al., 2010). This theoretical perspective is particularly relevant when applied to the domain of public administration, where institutions play a pivotal role in determining the norms, values, and structures that govern administrative processes. Within this framework, the institutional environment encompasses not only formal rules and regulations but also informal norms and cultural elements that collectively shape the behavioral patterns of organizations (Kamruzzaman, 2020).

In the case of Binh Duong province, the application of institutional theory offers a comprehensive lens through which to understand the intricate relationship between democratic institutions and the practices within the civil service. Binh Duong’s unique sociopolitical context, marked by a blend of rapid industrialization, economic growth, and democratic experimentation, necessitates an in-depth examination of how institutional factors influence the functioning of civil service practices. The democratic institutions in Binh Duong, ranging from local governance structures to participatory decision-making processes, form an integral part of the institutional environment that governs the province’s public administration (Thanh et al., 2022).

Examining how democratic institutions shape civil service practices in Binh Duong is not merely an academic pursuit but a pertinent endeavor with real-world implications. Understanding the influence of democratic institutions on civil service practices is crucial for gauging the effectiveness of governance structures in aligning with democratic ideals (Thanh et al., 2022). Furthermore, it holds implications for civil servants’ job satisfaction, as institutional arrangements directly affect the organizational culture, decision-making processes, and overall work environment.

By delving into the interplay between institutional factors and civil service practices in Binh Duong, this research seeks to unravel the mechanisms through which the institutional environment, characterized by democratic institutions, influences the professional experiences of civil servants. Such an investigation is paramount for advancing our comprehension of how institutional dynamics shape public administration in a context where democratic ideals intersect with the imperatives of economic progress (Hoa & Thanh, 2023). Consequently, the findings contribute to the academic discourse on institutional theory and the practical realm of policy formulation and administrative reforms in Binh Duong province.

FINDINGS

Participation and Empowerment:

Empirical findings derived from research endeavors underscore the significant impact of implementing democratic principles within state administrative agencies in Binh Duong on fostering the active involvement of civil servants in decision-making processes. This heightened participation, in turn, contributes substantively to cultivating a profound sense of empowerment and job satisfaction among public servants in the region. The research outcomes elucidate that a democratic administrative framework creates an environment wherein civil servants perceive their roles as integral to the policy development landscape (Cole, 2006). This perception is instrumental in shaping a more fulfilling career experience for public servants, as they recognize the tangible influence of their opinions on the formulation and evolution of policies. The empirical evidence thus illuminates a reciprocal relationship between democratic implementation and the enhancement of job satisfaction, underlining the pivotal role that participatory decision-making plays in fostering a work culture wherein civil servants feel valued, empowered, and content in their professional endeavors (Cornwall & Brock, 2005). This nuanced understanding underscores the significance of democratic governance in shaping administrative processes and directly influencing the subjective experiences and well-being of civil servants within the bureaucratic context of Binh Duong.

Transparency and Communication:

Empirical research findings illuminate that implementing democratic principles within state administrative agencies in Binh Duong catalyzes fostering transparency and establishing open communication channels. A democratic system, characterized by its commitment to openness and inclusivity, fundamentally promotes an organizational culture that prioritizes disseminating relevant information to civil servants. The availability of pertinent information, coupled with the cultivation of a communicative organizational ethos, emerges as a significant determinant influencing civil servants’ job satisfaction within such a democratic framework (Thøger Christensen, 2002).

In the context of democratic governance, civil servants who have access to comprehensive and timely information are positioned to make informed decisions, thereby contributing to a heightened sense of efficacy and job satisfaction. The research underscores the pivotal role that transparent communication plays in shaping a conducive work environment. This transparency, engendered by the democratic ethos, not only fosters trust among civil servants but also serves as a mitigating factor against uncertainty, which can often be a source of workplace stress. The clear articulation of policies, expectations, and organizational goals reduces ambiguity, thereby positively contributing to the overall work environment (Lustenberger & Rossi, 2018).

Moreover, the communicative nature inherent in democratic practices establishes a dynamic feedback loop wherein civil servants feel informed and empowered to express their viewpoints and concerns. This participatory aspect of communication within a democratic framework engenders a sense of inclusion and involvement among civil servants, further elevating their job satisfaction (Hoa & Thanh, 2023). The research findings suggest that the reciprocal nature of transparent communication and job satisfaction underscores the integral role that democratic governance plays in shaping not only administrative processes but also the psychosocial dimensions of the work experience for civil servants in Binh Duong. This nuanced understanding contributes to the broader discourse on the intersectionality of democratic principles and organizational dynamics within public administration (Jiang & Men, 2017).

Inclusive Governance Structures:

The empirical findings derived from research conducted on implementing democracy in state administrative agencies in Binh Duong underscore a significant dimension that extends beyond procedural aspects—the impact of inclusivity within governance structures on the job satisfaction of civil servants. Within the context of Binh Duong, the research reveals that the promotion of inclusivity, wherein diverse perspectives are acknowledged and considered in decision-making processes, constitutes a pivotal factor influencing the overall job satisfaction of civil servants operating within such a democratic framework (Gale & O’Toole, 2008).

The research outcomes illuminate a positive correlation between inclusive governance structures and heightened job satisfaction among civil servants in Binh Duong. When allowed to contribute diverse perspectives and experiences to the decision-making process, civil servants perceive their professional roles as more meaningful and impactful. This sense of involvement, stemming from recognizing diverse viewpoints, contributes substantively to a more fulfilling work experience.

Moreover, the research highlights that civil servants in Binh Duong derive satisfaction from a system that actively values diversity and inclusiveness. This extends beyond acknowledging diversity and encapsulates the integration of varied perspectives into administrative processes. Creating such a workplace environment, which reflects the broader spectrum of the province’s population, not only promotes equity and fairness but also fosters a sense of belonging among civil servants (Harvey, 2001).

The research findings reveal that inclusivity within governance structures contributes to a dynamic and harmonious workplace culture. The acknowledgment and integration of diverse perspectives not only enhance the quality of decision-making but also contribute to a more collaborative and cohesive organizational environment. The research outcomes thus underscore the importance of fostering inclusivity within democratic governance as a determinant of job satisfaction among civil servants in Binh Duong. This nuanced understanding contributes to the ongoing discourse on the organizational implications of democratic principles within public administration, providing valuable insights for both academic inquiry and practical policy considerations.

Professional Autonomy:

Empirical findings gleaned from research conducted on the implementation of democracy in state administrative agencies in Binh Duong province underscore a salient dimension with profound implications for the job satisfaction of civil servants—namely, the conferment of greater professional autonomy facilitated by democratic practices (Schutzenhofer, 1987). The research illuminates that the infusion of democratic principles within the administrative framework potentially grants civil servants an elevated degree of professional autonomy, affording them the latitude to exercise discretion and make independent decisions within the scope of their roles.

The research outcomes suggest that this heightened professional autonomy emerges as a significant determinant in influencing job satisfaction among civil servants in Binh Duong. Professional autonomy, characterized by the discretion to make decisions and the latitude to execute tasks independently, is a catalyst for engendering a sense of control over one’s work. This sense of control, in turn, becomes instrumental in cultivating an environment where civil servants feel empowered and capable of making meaningful contributions to their respective roles and the overarching organizational objectives.

As illuminated by the research findings, autonomy is positioned as a critical factor that resonates with the intrinsic motivations of civil servants (Hampton et al., 2020). The ability to exercise discretion and influence outcomes not only contributes to a more fulfilling professional experience but also aligns with the notion of self-determination, a critical psychological component in the realm of job satisfaction. The research suggests that the provision of autonomy within democratic governance structures acts as a mechanism through which civil servants derive satisfaction, fostering a work environment characterized by a heightened sense of efficacy and individual agency (Labrague et al., 2019).

Furthermore, the research underscores the reciprocal relationship between democratic implementation and the enhancement of job satisfaction, elucidating how the provision of autonomy represents a tangible manifestation of democratic principles positively impacting the professional lives of civil servants in Binh Duong. This nuanced understanding contributes valuable insights to the academic discourse surrounding the intersectionality of democratic practices and organizational dynamics within the context of public administration.

Adaptability to Local Context:

Empirical investigations into implementing democracy within state administrative agencies in Binh Duong province have yielded substantive research findings that underscore the critical importance of contextual adaptation of democratic practices. Examining how democratic principles are tailored to suit the specific local dynamics of Binh Duong emerges as a paramount facet requiring nuanced scrutiny. Binh Duong province’s distinctive socio-economic landscape, rapid industrialization, and heterogeneous demographic composition necessitate bespoke solutions that resonate with its unique challenges and opportunities.

The research findings posit that the efficacy of democratic implementation hinges significantly on its adaptability to the specific needs and nuances of Binh Duong. The province’s socio-economic dynamics, amid rapid industrialization, introduce a set of circumstances that demand a thoughtful calibration of democratic practices. Tailoring democratic solutions to align with the intricacies of Binh Duong’s industrial landscape becomes imperative for the effectiveness of governance structures.

Moreover, the province’s diverse population, spanning urban and rural areas, introduces complexities that warrant customized democratic approaches. Recognizing and accommodating the diverse needs, expectations, and socio-cultural nuances of the population is essential for ensuring that democratic governance resonates with the lived experiences of civil servants. The adaptability of democratic implementation to these local intricacies becomes a linchpin in influencing the satisfaction levels of civil servants, as it directly impacts the resonance of governance structures with the daily realities of those serving within the administrative agencies (Shen & Tsai, 2016).

The research outcomes suggest that the success of democratic implementation in Binh Duong province is contingent upon its ability to respond to the evolving socio-economic and demographic landscape flexibly. The adaptability of democratic practices, aligned with the province’s unique context, can enhance the satisfaction levels of civil servants by fostering a governance environment that is responsive and resonant with the diverse needs of the population it serves. This nuanced understanding contributes to the burgeoning academic discourse on the intersectionality of democratic governance and local contextual dynamics within the domain of public administration.

Public Service Motivation:

Empirical research outcomes spotlight the impact of implementing democratic principles within state administrative agencies in Binh Duong province, unveiling a nuanced dimension that transcends procedural considerations. The research suggests a noteworthy connection between democratic practices and the intrinsic motivation among civil servants to serve the public good. It posits that democratic governance, characterized by its emphasis on inclusivity, transparency, and participatory decision-making, aligns inherently with the altruistic motives that drive individuals to contribute meaningfully to societal well-being (Thanh et al., 2022).

The research findings illuminate that civil servants who perceive their roles within a democratic framework as integral to advancing the greater good of the community may be more inclined to experience heightened job satisfaction (Hoa & Thanh, 2023). The resonance between democratic governance and public service motivation becomes a salient determinant in shaping the subjective experiences of civil servants in Binh Duong. The perception that their contributions directly contribute to the broader community’s welfare engenders a sense of purpose and fulfillment, contributing to their overall job satisfaction.

Furthermore, the research underscores that the interplay between democratic governance and public service motivation is not merely theoretical but has practical implications for the organizational culture within state administrative agencies (Hoa & Thanh, 2023). Civil servants who find alignment between their values, driven by a commitment to public service, and the democratic ethos of the administrative framework are likely to derive increased satisfaction from their professional roles.

The connection between democratic practices and public service motivation, as illuminated by the research, emerges as a pivotal determinant of satisfaction among civil servants in Binh Duong. The research findings provide valuable insights into the motivational dynamics underpinning civil servants’ experiences, shedding light on the synergies between governance structures and individual aspirations. This nuanced understanding contributes to the ongoing academic discourse on the intersectionality of democratic governance, individual motivation, and organizational dynamics within public administration (Anh et al., 2024).

DISCUSSION

The research outcomes align with and extend the prevailing literature concerning the nexus between democratic implementation and civil servants’ job satisfaction. Academic figures such as Frederickson and Ghere (2005) accentuate the significance of participatory decision-making and unobstructed communication channels in augmenting job satisfaction, a sentiment echoed in the present study. The investigation discloses that introducing democratic principles within state administrative agencies in Binh Duong province positively impacts the sense of empowerment and job satisfaction among civil servants. This observation substantiates the broader scholarly discourse positing that democratic practices contribute significantly to a more gratifying professional milieu.

Furthermore, the correlation between democratic governance and public service motivation, as underscored by the findings, aligns with literature emphasizing the intrinsic motivation of civil servants to contribute to the collective welfare (Perry & Wise, 1990). The research contributes to this discourse by elucidating how democratic principles align with and potentially enhance this intrinsic motivation, ultimately influencing job satisfaction levels (Tuoi & Thanh, 2023).

The ramifications of democratic implementation on civil servants’ job satisfaction in Binh Duong province are multifaceted. The study underscores that participatory decision-making, transparent communication, and inclusive governance structures positively influence job satisfaction (Hoa & Thanh, 2023). This is contingent upon civil servants feeling involved, valued, and empowered, thereby fostering a conducive work environment. The adaptability of democratic practices to the unique contextual idiosyncrasies of Binh Duong, encompassing its diverse population and rapid economic changes, emerges as a pivotal determinant in evaluating the efficacy of governance structures and, by extension, job satisfaction.

Additionally, the heightened professional autonomy facilitated by democratic practices emerges as a substantive contributor to job satisfaction. The capacity of civil servants to exercise discretion in their roles aligns with extant literature emphasizing the paramount importance of autonomy in fostering job satisfaction (Hackman & Oldham, 1976). Policy initiatives should be formulated to tailor democratic practices to the specific socio-economic and demographic context of Binh Duong. This necessitates a nuanced recognition of the unique challenges posed by rapid industrialization, fostering adaptability in democratic governance structures.

Strategies that enhance the skills of civil servants in navigating and contributing to democratic decision-making processes can be instrumental. Training programs can empower civil servants, enabling them to make meaningful contributions and enhance their job satisfaction. Policy frameworks should emphasize the establishment of transparent communication channels within administrative agencies (Tuoi & Thanh, 2023).. Clear and open communication plays a pivotal role in reducing uncertainty and fostering trust, thereby positively impacting job satisfaction.

Longitudinal studies that track the evolution of job satisfaction among civil servants in response to ongoing democratic reforms can provide valuable insights into the sustainability of positive outcomes. Comparative analyses across provinces or regions with varying degrees of democratic implementation can furnish a broader understanding of the impact of democratic governance on job satisfaction. Regular surveys assessing employee engagement and satisfaction can offer real-time feedback, facilitating continuous improvement in democratic practices within administrative agencies (Hoa & Thanh, 2023). The research findings contribute valuable insights to the existing literature and furnish practical implications for policymakers seeking to enhance civil servants’ job satisfaction in Binh Duong province through effective democratic implementation. Subsequent research initiatives can further build upon these findings, fostering a more comprehensive understanding of the dynamic relationship between democratic governance and the professional experiences of civil servants.

CONCLUSION

The research illuminates several key findings regarding the relationship between democratic implementation and civil servants’ job satisfaction in Binh Duong province, Vietnam. The empirical evidence underscores that introducing democratic practices positively influences civil servants’ job satisfaction (Tuoi & Thanh, 2023). Specifically, participatory decision-making, transparent communication, and inclusive governance structures contribute to a heightened sense of empowerment and satisfaction among civil servants. The study also highlights the correlation between democratic governance and public service motivation, further enriching our understanding of the intrinsic drivers shaping civil servants’ satisfaction in a democratic context.

These findings hold substantial significance in the broader public administration and governance context. They contribute to the existing body of knowledge by affirming and extending the understanding that democratic principles are not only procedural but have tangible effects on civil servants’ well-being and professional fulfillment (Hoa & Thanh, 2023). The research adds granularity by emphasizing the adaptability of democratic practices to the specific socio-economic and demographic context of Binh Duong, recognizing the unique challenges posed by rapid industrialization and diverse population dynamics.

Moreover, the study provides nuanced insights into the role of professional autonomy in shaping job satisfaction, aligning with established literature on the importance of autonomy in organizational psychology. The connection between democratic governance and public service motivation, while acknowledged in existing literature, gains specificity through the study’s focus on the Vietnamese context, offering a deeper understanding of the motivational dynamics within this unique socio-political landscape (Thanh et al., 2021).

The contribution of this study lies in its empirical validation of theoretical concepts within the specific context of Binh Duong province. By bridging theory and practice, the research enriches the understanding of how democratic principles operate on the ground, affecting the day-to-day experiences of civil servants. This empirical foundation confirms the relevance of existing theories and provides a contextualized understanding of the mechanisms through which democratic practices impact job satisfaction (Hoa & Thanh, 2023).

Furthermore, the study extends the discourse on democratic governance and its implications for public servants, offering valuable insights for policymakers, practitioners, and scholars. The emphasis on tailoring democratic solutions to the local context, and recognizing the unique challenges and opportunities of Binh Duong provides actionable guidance for those involved in governance reforms and public administration in similar contexts.

Building on these findings, future research endeavors could explore the longitudinal effects of democratic reforms on the sustained job satisfaction of civil servants. A more extended study could track changes over time, providing a deeper understanding of the durability of positive outcomes and potential emerging challenges (Thanh et al., 2022).

Comparative analyses across provinces or regions within Vietnam, or even across different countries with varying democratic traditions, would contribute to a more comprehensive understanding of how contextual factors shape the relationship between democratic governance and job satisfaction. Additionally, investigating the perceptions and experiences of diverse demographic groups within civil service could reveal nuanced patterns and shed light on potential disparities. Further exploration of the interplay between democratic governance and specific aspects of job satisfaction, such as work-life balance or perceived fairness in promotions, could provide additional dimensions to the current understanding (Thanh et al., 2021).

This study serves as a substantive contribution to the literature by providing empirical evidence on the impact of democratic practices on civil servants’ job satisfaction in Binh Duong province. The nuanced insights generated pave the way for informed policy decisions and academic inquiry, fostering a deeper comprehension of the intricate dynamics of democratic governance and public service experiences.

REFERENCES

1. Anh, T. T. T., Anh, T. T. L., & Thanh, N. N. (2024). The impact of green tourism on the Hmong community in Vietnam. Multidisciplinary Science Journal, 6(4), 2024034-2024034.
2. Bettencourt, L. A., & Brown, S. W. (1997). Contact employees: Relationships among workplace fairness, job satisfaction and prosocial service behaviors. Journal of retailing, 73(1), 39-61.
3. Cameron, A. F., & Webster, J. (2011). Relational outcomes of multicommunicating: Integrating incivility and social exchange perspectives. Organization Science, 22(3), 754-771.
4. Cole, S. (2006). Cultural tourism, community participation and empowerment. Cultural tourism in a changing world: Politics, participation and (re) presentation, 89-103.
5. Cornforth, C. (2004). The governance of cooperatives and mutual associations: A paradox perspective. Annals of public and cooperative economics, 75(1), 11-32.
6. Cornwall, A., & Brock, K. (2005). Beyond buzzwords “poverty reduction”,“participation” and “empowerment” in development policy.
7. Fischer, F. (2009). Democracy and expertise: Reorienting policy inquiry. OUP Oxford.
8. Fox, O., & Stoett, P. (2016). Citizen participation in the UN Sustainable Development Goals consultation process: Toward global democratic governance. Global Governance, 22, 555.
9. Fung, A., & Wright, E. O. (2001). Deepening democracy: Innovations in empowered participatory governance. Politics & society, 29(1), 5-41.
10. Gale, R., & O’Toole, T. (2008). Learning from political sociology: Structure, agency and inclusive governance. The International Journal of Children’s Rights, 16(3), 369-378.
11. Hampton, K. B., Smeltzer, S. C., & Ross, J. G. (2020). Evaluating the transition from nursing student to practicing nurse: An integrative review. Journal of Professional Nursing, 36(6), 551-559.
12. Harvey, J. (2001). The role of sport and recreation policy in fostering citizenship: The Canadian experience. Building citizenship: Governance and service provision in Canada, 23-45.
13. Hoa, N. T. T., & Thanh, N. N. (2023). Factors Affecting Corruption Control in Public Administration: Evidence from Vietnam. Journal of Law and Sustainable Development, 11(12), e1636-e1636.
14. Jiang, H., & Men, R. L. (2017). Creating an engaged workforce: The impact of authentic leadership, transparent organizational communication, and work-life enrichment. Communication research, 44(2), 225-243.
15. Kamruzzaman, P. (2020). Exploring the nexus between participation and empowerment. Journal of Development Policy and Practice, 5(1), 32-53.
16. Kettl, D. F. (2015). The transformation of governance: Public administration for the twenty-first century. Jhu Press.
17. Kettl, D. F. (2015). The transformation of governance: Public administration for the twenty-first century. Jhu Press.
18. Labrague, L. J., McEnroe‐Petitte, D. M., & Tsaras, K. (2019). Predictors and outcomes of nurse professional autonomy: A cross‐sectional study. International journal of nursing practice, 25(1), e12711.
19. Lee, C., Abdullah, A. G. K., Ismail, A., & Alizydeen, N. J. (2011). How democratic leaders empower teachers job satisfaction? The Malaysian case. International Journal of Business and Social Science, 2(10), 251-257.
20. Li, N., Liang, J., & Crant, J. M. (2010). The role of proactive personality in job satisfaction and organizational citizenship behavior: a relational perspective. Journal of applied psychology, 95(2), 395.
21. London, J. (2013). Vietnam and the making of market Leninism. In Contemporary Authoritarianism in Southeast Asia (pp. 37-61). Routledge.
22. Lustenberger, T., & Rossi, E. (2018). Does central bank transparency and communication affect financial and macroeconomic forecasts? (No. 2018/06). WWZ Working Paper.
23. Meijer, A. (2013). Understanding the complex dynamics of transparency. Public administration review, 73(3), 429-439.
24. Men, L. R. (2014). Strategic internal communication: Transformational leadership, communication channels, and employee satisfaction. Management communication quarterly, 28(2), 264-284.
25. Neff, J. F. (2008). Workplace social exchange network: Effects of its relationship with job satisfaction and organizational commitment. Alliant International University, Los Angeles.
26. Ritz, A., Brewer, G. A., & Neumann, O. (2016). Public service motivation: A systematic literature review and outlook. Public Administration Review, 76(3), 414-426.
27. Schutzenhofer, K. K. (1987). The measurement of professional autonomy. Journal of Professional Nursing, 3(5), 278-283.
28. Shen, X., & Tsai, K. S. (2016). Institutional adaptability in China: Local developmental models under changing economic conditions. World Development, 87, 107-127.
29. Thanh, N. N., Thuy, H. T. T., Hoa, N. T. T., & Thien, N. D. (2022). The relationship between ethical leadership, job engagement, and job performance: evidence from the public sector in Vietnam. PalArch’s Journal of Archaeology of Egypt/Egyptology, 19(2), 1161-1176.
30. Thanh, N. N., Trung, N. S., & Thien, N. D. (2021). A case study on the people’s participation in local governance in Vietnam. Turkish Online Journal of Qualitative Inquiry, 12(9). 4107-4116
31. Thanh, N. N., Tung, P. H., Thu, N. H., Kien, P. D., & Nguyet, N. A. (2021). Factors affecting the share of fake news about covid-19 outbreak on social networks in vietnam. Journal of Liberty and International Affairs, 7(3), 179-195.
32. Thøger Christensen, L. (2002). Corporate communication: The challenge of transparency. Corporate communications: an international journal, 7(3), 162-168.
33. Tuoi, N. T., & Thanh, N. N. (2023). The Impact of Digital Capabilities on the Work Performance of Provincial Civil Servants in Vietnam. Journal of Law and Sustainable Development, 11(4), e560-e560.
34. Van Knippenberg, D., & Sleebos, E. (2006). Organizational identification versus organizational commitment: self‐definition, social exchange, and job attitudes. Journal of Organizational Behavior: The International Journal of Industrial, Occupational and Organizational Psychology and Behavior, 27(5), 571-584.
35. Welch, E. W., Hinnant, C. C., & Moon, M. J. (2005). Linking citizen satisfaction with e-government and trust in government. Journal of public administration research and theory, 15(3), 371-391.